{"formatVersion":"1.1","id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","path":"/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","title":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around?","family":"Answers detail","description":"A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together.","language":"en-US","access":{"audience":"custom-shared-preview","indexable":true},"provenance":{"sourceUrl":"https://www.mentalhealth.com/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","wordpressId":"6115","contentCompleteness":"complete","dateScope":"original-source"},"authors":[{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers#person","name":"Ann Landers","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers"}],"reviewer":{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson#person","name":"Jesse Hanson, Ph.D.","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson"},"dates":{"datePublished":"2025-07-16T08:41:42Z","dateModified":"2026-06-13T13:28:29Z","lastReviewed":"2025-09-15"},"content":{"html":"<nav class=\"breadcrumbs\" aria-label=\"Breadcrumb\"><ol><li><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/\">Home</a></li><li><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers\">Answers</a></li><li><span aria-current=\"page\">Can we have a future if his ex is still around?</span></li></ol></nav><div class=\"article-page answer-page\" data-answer-template=\"conversation\"><header class=\"answer-heading article-heading\"><a class=\"answer-back\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers\">Answers</a><h1>Can we have a future if his ex is still around?</h1><div class=\"answer-credits\"><a class=\"answer-credit-person\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9419.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"40\" height=\"40\" loading=\"lazy\"><span><span class=\"answer-credit-role\">Written by</span><span class=\"answer-credit-name\">Ann Landers</span></span></a><a class=\"answer-credit-person\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9210.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"40\" height=\"40\" loading=\"lazy\"><span><span class=\"answer-credit-role\">Medically reviewed by</span><span class=\"answer-credit-name\">Jesse Hanson, Ph.D.</span></span></a></div><dl class=\"answer-heading-dates\"><div><dt>Published</dt><dd><time datetime=\"2025-07-16T08:41:42Z\">July 16, 2025</time></dd></div><div><dt>Updated</dt><dd><time datetime=\"2026-06-13T13:28:29Z\">June 13, 2026</time></dd></div><div><dt>Reviewed</dt><dd><time datetime=\"2025-09-15\">September 15, 2025</time></dd></div></dl></header><nav class=\"answer-nav\" aria-label=\"Answer navigation\"><a href=\"#summary\">Summary</a><a href=\"#question\">Question</a><a href=\"#answer\">Answer</a></nav><article class=\"prose\" id=\"article-content\" data-answer-thread aria-label=\"Reader question and professional response\"><section class=\"answer-overview\" id=\"summary\" aria-labelledby=\"summary-title\"><h2 id=\"summary-title\">Summary</h2><figure class=\"answer-question-image\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/library/editorial-13390.webp\" alt=\"Two women share a laugh while sitting together on a sofa.\" width=\"1200\" height=\"600\" fetchpriority=\"high\"></figure><p>A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together. They ask whether patiently waiting will lead him to choose an exclusive relationship.</p><p>The response says his future choices cannot be predicted, but highlights the difference between his definition of friendship and the reader’s expectations.</p><p>It emphasizes that the reader can ask clearly for exclusivity and decide whether to leave if those needs are not met, rather than assuming time alone will change an arrangement that currently suits him.</p></section><div class=\"answer-originals\" id=\"original-conversation\"><div class=\"answer-originals-body\"><section class=\"answer-post answer-question\" id=\"question\" aria-labelledby=\"question-person\"><div class=\"answer-avatar answer-reader\" aria-hidden=\"true\">?</div><div class=\"answer-post-content\"><header class=\"answer-person\"><h2 id=\"question-person\">Question</h2><span>Reader · Identity withheld</span></header><p>My boyfriend and I have been in a warm, caring relationship for about 13 months. We have a lot in common: travel, values, and life goals and we’ve been talking about our future together in the next 2 to 3 years.</p>\n<p>Before we met, he had already ended things with his ex. He told me they were just friends but eight months into our relationship I found out that she still comes over sometimes to do a <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexual-disorders\" class=\"article-inline-link\">specific kinky sexual favor for him</a>. I was shocked and upset.</p>\n<p>He says he doesn’t want to lose me and that I have wonderful qualities that he never found in his ex and that he still wants to build a future with me. He also says he’s known his ex for about seven years and can’t just cut her off completely.</p>\n<p>I’m trying to be patient and <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationship-challenges\" class=\"article-inline-link\">not let jealousy take over</a>. I keep hoping this situation will end soon and that he’ll fully choose me but I wonder: is he still in love with her? Will he decide their history matters more than what we have? Is he truly sincere and planning a future with me where she’s no longer involved?</p></div></section><section class=\"answer-post answer-response\" id=\"answer\" aria-labelledby=\"response-person\"><a class=\"answer-avatar\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers\" aria-label=\"View Ann Landers profile\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9419.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"44\" height=\"44\" loading=\"lazy\"></a><div class=\"answer-post-content\"><header class=\"answer-person\"><h2 id=\"response-person\">Answer</h2><span>Ann Landers</span></header><p>There is no way to tell for sure what your boyfriend will do in the future. However, it is clear that his definition of “friend” is substantially different than your own.</p>\n<p>Your boyfriend is currently having his cake and eating it too. He gets the <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexuality\" class=\"article-inline-link\">kinky sex he wants from his ex</a> and then goes back to you for <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationships-support\" class=\"article-inline-link\">warmth and caring</a>. His needs are being met fairly well right now. Why on earth would he be motivated to give up either of you under these circumstances?</p>\n<p>Think about it – the chances are low that your “waiting around” strategy will result in his seeing the light and breaking off contact with his ex. I don’t for a minute buy his excuse about how his history with his ex requires him to continue to remain in contact with her.</p>\n<p>People break off contact with ex-lovers every day – when they are motivated to do so. He isn’t. The real issue here is how long it will take before you understand that you have a right to <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/case-studies\" class=\"article-inline-link\">have your own needs met</a> – including your need for exclusivity with the man you love. It is okay to ask him for this – and to leave him if he won’t give you what you need. Have strength.</p>\n<p>– Anne</p></div></section></div></div></article><div class=\"answer-endmatter\"><section class=\"article-expert answer-expert-card\" aria-label=\"Subject matter expert\" data-expert-kind=\"related\"><a class=\"answer-card-avatar\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel\" tabindex=\"-1\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/13152.jpeg\" alt=\"\" width=\"64\" height=\"64\" loading=\"lazy\"></a><div class=\"answer-expert-copy\"><p class=\"article-bio-role\">Subject matter expert</p><h2><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel\">Carlos Protzel <span class=\"expert-credentials\">Psy.D.</span></a></h2><p class=\"article-expert-focus\">Integrative mental health care</p><a class=\"profile-experience-link experience-button\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel\">View experience</a></div></section><section class=\"article-topic-community\" aria-label=\"Related communities\"><img class=\"topic-community-banner\" src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/library/editorial-17221.webp\" alt=\"\" width=\"48\" height=\"48\" loading=\"lazy\"><p class=\"topic-community-label\">Related communities</p><h2>Relationships</h2><p>Connect around communication, closeness, boundaries, and the relationships that matter to you.</p><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/community/relationships\">Explore community</a></section><section class=\"answer-author-card answer-reviewer-card\"><a class=\"answer-card-avatar\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9419.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"64\" height=\"64\" loading=\"lazy\"></a><div><span class=\"answer-reviewer-label\">Author</span><h2><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers\">Ann Landers</a></h2><p>Ann Landers was the leading advice columnist for 47 years, with her widely syndicated columns reaching 90 million readers worldwide.</p><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers\" class=\"profile-experience-link experience-button\">View experience</a></div></section><section class=\"answer-author-card answer-reviewer-card\"><a class=\"answer-card-avatar\" href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson\"><img src=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9210.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"64\" height=\"64\" loading=\"lazy\"></a><div><span class=\"answer-reviewer-label\">Medical reviewer</span><h2><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson\">Jesse Hanson, Ph.D.</a></h2><p>Jesse Hanson, Ph.D., is a clinical and somatic psychologist with over 20 years of experience in neuropsychology, specializing in integrative, mind-body…</p><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson\" class=\"profile-experience-link experience-button\">View experience</a></div></section><section class=\"answer-related\"><h2>Related questions</h2><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/uncomfortable-around-my-boyfriend\">Why do I feel uncomfortable around my boyfriend?</a><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/my-boyfriend-still-has-his-ex-girlfriends-photos\">Why does my boyfriend still have photos of his ex?</a><a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/my-boyfriend-saved-pictures-of-his-ex-girlfriend-on-his-computer\">Why does my boyfriend still have pictures of his ex-girlfriend?</a></section></div></div>","text":"HomeAnswersCan we have a future if his ex is still around?AnswersCan we have a future if his ex is still around?Written byAnn LandersMedically reviewed byJesse Hanson, Ph.D.PublishedJuly 16, 2025UpdatedJune 13, 2026ReviewedSeptember 15, 2025SummaryQuestionAnswerSummaryA reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together. They ask whether patiently waiting will lead him to choose an exclusive relationship.The response says his future choices cannot be predicted, but highlights the difference between his definition of friendship and the reader’s expectations.It emphasizes that the reader can ask clearly for exclusivity and decide whether to leave if those needs are not met, rather than assuming time alone will change an arrangement that currently suits him.?QuestionReader · Identity withheldMy boyfriend and I have been in a warm, caring relationship for about 13 months. We have a lot in common: travel, values, and life goals and we’ve been talking about our future together in the next 2 to 3 years. Before we met, he had already ended things with his ex. He told me they were just friends but eight months into our relationship I found out that she still comes over sometimes to do a specific kinky sexual favor for him. I was shocked and upset. He says he doesn’t want to lose me and that I have wonderful qualities that he never found in his ex and that he still wants to build a future with me. He also says he’s known his ex for about seven years and can’t just cut her off completely. I’m trying to be patient and not let jealousy take over. I keep hoping this situation will end soon and that he’ll fully choose me but I wonder: is he still in love with her? Will he decide their history matters more than what we have? Is he truly sincere and planning a future with me where she’s no longer involved?AnswerAnn LandersThere is no way to tell for sure what your boyfriend will do in the future. However, it is clear that his definition of “friend” is substantially different than your own. Your boyfriend is currently having his cake and eating it too. He gets the kinky sex he wants from his ex and then goes back to you for warmth and caring. His needs are being met fairly well right now. Why on earth would he be motivated to give up either of you under these circumstances? Think about it – the chances are low that your “waiting around” strategy will result in his seeing the light and breaking off contact with his ex. I don’t for a minute buy his excuse about how his history with his ex requires him to continue to remain in contact with her. People break off contact with ex-lovers every day – when they are motivated to do so. He isn’t. The real issue here is how long it will take before you understand that you have a right to have your own needs met – including your need for exclusivity with the man you love. It is okay to ask him for this – and to leave him if he won’t give you what you need. Have strength. – AnneSubject matter expertCarlos Protzel Psy.D.Integrative mental health careView experienceRelated communitiesRelationshipsConnect around communication, closeness, boundaries, and the relationships that matter to you.Explore communityAuthorAnn LandersAnn Landers was the leading advice columnist for 47 years, with her widely syndicated columns reaching 90 million readers worldwide.View experienceMedical reviewerJesse Hanson, Ph.D.Jesse Hanson, Ph.D., is a clinical and somatic psychologist with over 20 years of experience in neuropsychology, specializing in integrative, mind-body…View experienceRelated questionsWhy do I feel uncomfortable around my boyfriend?Why does my boyfriend still have photos of his ex?Why does my boyfriend still have pictures of his ex-girlfriend?","wordCount":627},"schema":{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#organization","name":"MentalHealth.com","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/"},{"@type":"WebSite","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#website","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/","name":"MentalHealth.com","inLanguage":"en-US","publisher":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#organization"}},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Answers","item":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":3,"name":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around?","item":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too"}]},{"@type":"ImageObject","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#primaryimage","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too-20261003.webp","contentUrl":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too-20261003.webp","width":1000,"height":667,"encodingFormat":"image/webp","caption":"Two women walking along an open coastal boardwalk"},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers#person","name":"Ann Landers","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","jobTitle":"Writer (In remembrance)","image":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9419.jpg"},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson#person","name":"Jesse Hanson, Ph.D.","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson","jobTitle":"Clinical Affairs Director","image":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9210.jpg","sameAs":["https://www.linkedin.com/in/jesse-hanson-phd-7215216/"]},{"@type":"Article","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#article","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","headline":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around?","description":"A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together.","wordCount":511,"mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#webpage"},"publisher":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#organization"},"articleSection":"Answers","inLanguage":"en-US","datePublished":"2025-07-16T08:41:42Z","dateModified":"2026-06-13T13:28:29Z","author":[{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers#person"}],"image":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#primaryimage"},"hasPart":[{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question"},{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer"}]},{"@type":"Question","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question","name":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around?","text":"My boyfriend and I have been in a warm, caring relationship for about 13 months. We have a lot in common: travel, values, and life goals and we’ve been talking about our future together in the next 2 to 3 years. Before we met, he had already ended things with his ex. He told me they were just friends but eight months into our relationship I found out that she still comes over sometimes to do a specific kinky sexual favor for him. I was shocked and upset. He says he doesn’t want to lose me and that I have wonderful qualities that he never found in his ex and that he still wants to build a future with me. He also says he’s known his ex for about seven years and can’t just cut her off completely. I’m trying to be patient and not let jealousy take over. I keep hoping this situation will end soon and that he’ll fully choose me but I wonder: is he still in love with her? Will he decide their history matters more than what we have? Is he truly sincere and planning a future with me where she’s no longer involved?","acceptedAnswer":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer"},"inLanguage":"en-US","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question","answerCount":1},{"@type":"Answer","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer","text":"There is no way to tell for sure what your boyfriend will do in the future. However, it is clear that his definition of “friend” is substantially different than your own. Your boyfriend is currently having his cake and eating it too. He gets the kinky sex he wants from his ex and then goes back to you for warmth and caring. His needs are being met fairly well right now. Why on earth would he be motivated to give up either of you under these circumstances? Think about it – the chances are low that your “waiting around” strategy will result in his seeing the light and breaking off contact with his ex. I don’t for a minute buy his excuse about how his history with his ex requires him to continue to remain in contact with her. People break off contact with ex-lovers every day – when they are motivated to do so. He isn’t. The real issue here is how long it will take before you understand that you have a right to have your own needs met – including your need for exclusivity with the man you love. It is okay to ask him for this – and to leave him if he won’t give you what you need. Have strength. – Anne","author":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers#person"},"inLanguage":"en-US","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer"},{"@type":"MedicalWebPage","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#webpage","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","name":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around?","description":"A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together.","inLanguage":"en-US","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#website"},"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#breadcrumb"},"mainEntity":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#article"},"publisher":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/#organization"},"medicalAudience":{"@type":"MedicalAudience","audienceType":"General public"},"datePublished":"2025-07-16T08:41:42Z","dateModified":"2026-06-13T13:28:29Z","lastReviewed":"2025-09-15","primaryImageOfPage":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#primaryimage"},"image":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#primaryimage"},"reviewedBy":{"@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson#person"}}]},"representations":{"html":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","json":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/data/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too.json","jsonLd":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/data/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too.ld.json"},"$schema":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/data/page.schema.json","images":[{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9419.jpg","alt":"","width":40,"height":40},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/9210.jpg","alt":"","width":40,"height":40},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/library/editorial-13390.webp","alt":"Two women share a laugh while sitting together on a sofa.","width":1200,"height":600},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/wordpress/13152.jpeg","alt":"","width":64,"height":64},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/library/editorial-17221.webp","alt":"","width":48,"height":48}],"sections":[{"id":"summary-title","title":"Summary","level":2,"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#summary-title"},{"id":"question-person","title":"Question","level":2,"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question-person"},{"id":"response-person","title":"Answer","level":2,"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#response-person"}],"references":[],"relatedReading":[],"links":[{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/","label":"Home"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers","label":"Answers"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers","label":"Answers"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","label":"Written byAnn Landers"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson","label":"Medically reviewed byJesse Hanson, Ph.D."},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#summary","label":"Summary"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question","label":"Question"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer","label":"Answer"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexual-disorders","label":"specific kinky sexual favor for him"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationship-challenges","label":"not let jealousy take over"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","label":""},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexuality","label":"kinky sex he wants from his ex"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationships-support","label":"warmth and caring"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/case-studies","label":"have your own needs met"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel","label":""},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel","label":"Carlos Protzel Psy.D."},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/carlos-protzel","label":"View experience"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/community/relationships","label":"Explore community"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","label":""},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","label":"Ann Landers"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers","label":"View experience"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson","label":""},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson","label":"Jesse Hanson, Ph.D."},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson","label":"View experience"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/uncomfortable-around-my-boyfriend","label":"Why do I feel uncomfortable around my boyfriend?"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/my-boyfriend-still-has-his-ex-girlfriends-photos","label":"Why does my boyfriend still have photos of his ex?"},{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/my-boyfriend-saved-pictures-of-his-ex-girlfriend-on-his-computer","label":"Why does my boyfriend still have pictures of his ex-girlfriend?"}],"conversation":{"status":"complete","summary":{"question":"A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together. They ask whether patiently waiting will lead him to choose an exclusive relationship.","answer":"The response says his future choices cannot be predicted, but highlights the difference between his definition of friendship and the reader’s expectations. It emphasizes that the reader can ask clearly for exclusivity and decide whether to leave if those needs are not met, rather than assuming time alone will change an arrangement that currently suits him."},"sourceUrl":"https://www.mentalhealth.com/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","sourceReviewer":{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson#person","name":"Jesse Hanson, Ph.D.","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/jesse-hanson"},"question":{"id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#question","html":"<p>My boyfriend and I have been in a warm, caring relationship for about 13 months. We have a lot in common: travel, values, and life goals and we’ve been talking about our future together in the next 2 to 3 years.</p>\n<p>Before we met, he had already ended things with his ex. He told me they were just friends but eight months into our relationship I found out that she still comes over sometimes to do a <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexual-disorders\">specific kinky sexual favor for him</a>. I was shocked and upset.</p>\n<p>He says he doesn’t want to lose me and that I have wonderful qualities that he never found in his ex and that he still wants to build a future with me. He also says he’s known his ex for about seven years and can’t just cut her off completely.</p>\n<p>I’m trying to be patient and <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationship-challenges\">not let jealousy take over</a>. I keep hoping this situation will end soon and that he’ll fully choose me but I wonder: is he still in love with her? Will he decide their history matters more than what we have? Is he truly sincere and planning a future with me where she’s no longer involved?</p>","text":"My boyfriend and I have been in a warm, caring relationship for about 13 months. We have a lot in common: travel, values, and life goals and we’ve been talking about our future together in the next 2 to 3 years. Before we met, he had already ended things with his ex. He told me they were just friends but eight months into our relationship I found out that she still comes over sometimes to do a specific kinky sexual favor for him. I was shocked and upset. He says he doesn’t want to lose me and that I have wonderful qualities that he never found in his ex and that he still wants to build a future with me. He also says he’s known his ex for about seven years and can’t just cut her off completely. I’m trying to be patient and not let jealousy take over. I keep hoping this situation will end soon and that he’ll fully choose me but I wonder: is he still in love with her? Will he decide their history matters more than what we have? Is he truly sincere and planning a future with me where she’s no longer involved?"},"answer":{"id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too#answer","html":"<p>There is no way to tell for sure what your boyfriend will do in the future. However, it is clear that his definition of “friend” is substantially different than your own.</p>\n<p>Your boyfriend is currently having his cake and eating it too. He gets the <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/sexuality\">kinky sex he wants from his ex</a> and then goes back to you for <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/relationships-support\">warmth and caring</a>. His needs are being met fairly well right now. Why on earth would he be motivated to give up either of you under these circumstances?</p>\n<p>Think about it – the chances are low that your “waiting around” strategy will result in his seeing the light and breaking off contact with his ex. I don’t for a minute buy his excuse about how his history with his ex requires him to continue to remain in contact with her.</p>\n<p>People break off contact with ex-lovers every day – when they are motivated to do so. He isn’t. The real issue here is how long it will take before you understand that you have a right to <a href=\"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/library/case-studies\">have your own needs met</a> – including your need for exclusivity with the man you love. It is okay to ask him for this – and to leave him if he won’t give you what you need. Have strength.</p>\n<p>– Anne</p>","text":"There is no way to tell for sure what your boyfriend will do in the future. However, it is clear that his definition of “friend” is substantially different than your own. Your boyfriend is currently having his cake and eating it too. He gets the kinky sex he wants from his ex and then goes back to you for warmth and caring. His needs are being met fairly well right now. Why on earth would he be motivated to give up either of you under these circumstances? Think about it – the chances are low that your “waiting around” strategy will result in his seeing the light and breaking off contact with his ex. I don’t for a minute buy his excuse about how his history with his ex requires him to continue to remain in contact with her. People break off contact with ex-lovers every day – when they are motivated to do so. He isn’t. The real issue here is how long it will take before you understand that you have a right to have your own needs met – including your need for exclusivity with the man you love. It is okay to ask him for this – and to leave him if he won’t give you what you need. Have strength. – Anne","author":{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers#person","name":"Ann Landers","url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/people/anne-landers"}},"summaryScope":"Editorial overview of the original question and response; original review dates apply to the source conversation."},"presentation":{"updatedAt":"2026-10-03","template":"answer-conversation","imageGeneratedAt":"2026-10-03"},"seo":{"title":"Can we have a future if his ex is still around? | MentalHealth.com","description":"A reader discovered that a boyfriend continues a sexual relationship with an ex while promising a future together.","canonical":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/answers/having-cake-and-eating-it-too","robots":"index,follow","socialImage":{"url":"https://mentalhealth-v2.workspace-454808.chatgpt.site/assets/social-tiles-20261006-dots/answers.png","width":1200,"height":630,"alt":"MentalHealth.com — Answers","type":"image/png","sitemapGroup":"answers"}},"subjectMatterExpert":{"name":"Carlos Protzel, Psy.D.","url":"/people/carlos-protzel","profileId":"13151","topic":"wellbeing","focus":"Integrative mental health care","selectionBasis":"Documented expertise in the existing published profile","reviewAttribution":false},"navigation":[],"relatedCommunity":{"community":"/community/relationships","basis":"topic match"},"collections":[]}
